June 3, 2004
Lawrence W. Crow, Jr.
Rodgers, (863) 534-6217 OR (863) 819-1856, Pager
Suspect Charged in 1991 Homicide Case
A joint investigation by the PCSO Homicide
Unit, the FDLE and the Lake Alfred Police Department resulted today in a
grand jury indictment against a suspect for the 1991 murder of Lake
Alfred resident Maggie Rigsbee.
A Polk County grand jury handed down an indictment today charging James
Arthur Holloway, DOB 1/23/53, with First Degree Murder and Burglary in
the strangling death of Rigsbee.
Holloway currently is incarcerated in the Florida State Prison system,
serving a 30-year sentence for 1991 attempted murder and sexual battery
cases (Lake Hamilton Police Department cases).
On March 2, 1991, the body of Maggie Rigsbee was found in the bedroom
of her home, located at 510 Tangerine Avenue in Lake Alfred. The Medical
Examiner determined she had been strangled to death.
PCSO Cold Case Homicide Detective Scott Rench recently re-opened the
case and began aggressively pursuing the investigation, which focused on
Holloway as a primary suspect. Holloway was scheduled to be released
from prison this year, after serving approximately half of a 30-year
During the recent investigation, detectives were able to obtain DNA
evidence from Holloway following an interview with him in which he
discarded a toothpick containing his DNA. Holloway's DNA proved to be a
positive match to DNA evidence found under the victim's fingernails.
Undersheriff, Division Commanders, Communications, News Media
A text only version of this release is also available.